Spotlight Story

Why Good People Do Bad Things

Image of Why Good People Do Bad Things

Steps can be taken to pinpoint and foil premeditated corporate and white-collar crime committed by workers trying to beat the system for their own self-interest. But what about wrongdoing committed by workers who unwittingly engage in illegal activities that become woven into the fabric of the company?

Professor Michael Maher, an authority on financial fraud and auditing, and Professor Donald Palmer, an expert on organizational behavior and corporate governance, recently joined forces to explore why ethical people may engage in criminal acts—and what corporations can do to prevent it.

Their study, “Developing the Process Model of Collective Corruption,” was published in the December issue of the Journal of Management Inquiry. Palmer gives the topic longer treatment as “Extending the Process Model of Collective Corruption,” a chapter in the forthcoming annual Research in Organizational Behavior (JAI Press, September 2007).

Much corporate wrongdoing is the result of mindless behavior, the product of mundane organizational structures such as rules, hierarchy, standard operating procedures and the division of labor.–Professor Donald Palmer

Their research probes such scandals as the Ford Motor Company’s Pinto, American Home Products’ Fen-Phen, B.F. Goodrich’s brake fraud case and the fixing of two television game shows. Their joint article also discusses several insidertrading scandals on Wall Street in the 1980s.

“Most of the cases we look at involve ordinary people doing ordinary things,” said Maher, who once quit a job because he was asked to “push the envelope” on valuing a piece of property.

Their findings: contrary to popular perception, much corporate and white-collar crime is not the result of deliberately illegal  actions consciously undertaken for personal or organizational gain.

Instead, said Palmer, “Much wrongdoing is the result of mindless behavior, the product of mundane organizational structures such as rules, hierarchy, standard operating procedures and the division of labor. Informal power relationships, incomplete information, professional norms, even technology can all play a role in creating an environment that fosters a collective corruption.”

Problems occur when a line is crossed—and crossed again and again—in the routine of getting the job done. Actions reach a tipping point when the everyday turns criminal.

“If you keep pushing the speed limit, each increment isn’t much, but it adds up,” noted Maher.

“Every small indiscretion brings a rationalization, which in turn lays the foundation for the next slightly more significant indiscretion,” explained Palmer, who teaches a course on the causes of corporate and white-collar crime.

Palmer said many factors can start someone down such a path. “The simplest is formal authority, when a manager instructs an employee to follow a questionable course of action, and the employee obeys, because that’s what subordinates are supposed to do in organizations—obey their managers.”

If organizations want to ensure they operate within the law, Maher and Palmer conclude, managers’ efforts must extend beyond awareness and prevention of deliberately unethical activities.

They also need to keep a keen eye out for the less obvious organizational structures that could potentially result in criminal activity.

Popular measures aimed at reducing corporate and white-collar crime, such as ethics training and legal reforms, are important but of limited value. According to Maher, “These approaches assume that people are predisposed to do wrong or that they make decisions based on cost-benefit calculations or a deliberate assessment of what’s considered the norm in their environment.”

Commands

Twitter Feed

Loading tweets...

News Release

UC Davis Part-Time MBA Ranked in Nation’s Top 9%
Fourth Consecutive Year among U.S News & World Report's Premier Programs

Image of UC Davis Part-Time MBA Ranked in Nation’s Top 9%

(Davis, CA) — The UC Davis Part-Time MBA program offered in Sacramento and the San Francisco Bay Area is ranked among the top 9% in the U.S., according to U.S. News & World Report’s latest graduate business school rankings.

At No. 29, this is the fourth consecutive year the UC Davis Part-Time MBA program is among the top AACSB International-accredited part-time MBA programs surveyed. This year, there were 323 part-time MBA programs surveyed.

News Release

UC Davis Full-Time MBA Ranked among Nation’s Premier Programs for 20th Consecutive Year
MBA Programs among Top 10% in U.S.
Record Salary and Bonus

Image of UC Davis Full-Time MBA Ranked among Nation’s Premier Programs for 20th Consecutive Year

(Davis, CA) — The UC Davis Graduate School of Management’s Full-Time MBA program is ranked among the premier business schools in the nation for the 20th consecutive year, according to U.S. News & World Report’s latest graduate business school rankings released today.

U.S. News’ latest ranking places the Full-Time MBA program at No. 48, placing it among the top 10% of the 464 Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business International’s accredited full-time MBA programs surveyed.

Key statistics from the School’s Full-Time MBA ranking include:

News Release

UC Davis Graduate School of Management partners with Lawrence Livermore and Sandia National Labs to drive technologies from lab to market

Image of UC Davis Graduate School of Management partners with Lawrence Livermore and Sandia National Labs to drive technologies from lab to market

(Davis, Calif.) – With a joint goal of speeding the transfer of new technologies from the laboratory to the commercial marketplace, the UC Davis Graduate School of Management, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and Sandia National Laboratories have announced a new partnership for researchers to develop their entrepreneurial skills.

Spotlight Story

Vickie Sherman MBA 13 Finds Her Passion, Her Career—and Herself

Image of Vickie Sherman MBA 13 Finds Her Passion, Her Career—and Herself

What opportunities, decisions, events have shaped your professional life?

My career path has been a climb across a jungle gym rather than a tangent up a corporate ladder. As a child, I used to thumb through the three-inch JCPenney catalogue, picking out the professional women who I would grow to be. I wanted to rule the world from a corner office in a suit and heels. I wanted to shed my humble origins and become Corporate Barbie.

Spotlight Story

MBA Student Consultants Make an IMPACT
Projects Put Business Needs Front and Center

Image of MBA Student Consultants Make an IMPACT

Agilent Technologies’ Electronic Measurement Group is a $3.6 billion business that over the past decade has seen a dramatic shift in its customer base from U.S., and Western European customers to predominantly Asia-based customers. Today, the majority of the division’s revenues are generated outside of the U.S., with an increasing concentration in China.